Restorative Practices and Disproportionate Discipline of Black Girls
An Intersectional and Ecological Analysis
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18060/28070Keywords:
Black girls, disproportionate discipline, restorative justice practices, intersectionalityAbstract
This mixed-methods study examines the disproportionate discipline of Black girls attending a U.S. high school implementing restorative justice practices. Grounded in ecological systems theory and intersectionality, this study presents overall and within-gender disciplinary outcomes, with qualitative data providing context for these trends. Quantitative analyses, including a relative risk index and Pearson’s chi-square tests, confirm significant overall and within-gender disparities in disciplinary outcomes. Qualitative findings reveal inconsistent discipline practices and classroom management challenges as pathways to inequity, exacerbated by subjective enforcement and punitive measures. The study underscores the need for consistent, equitable application of restorative practices and intentional relationship-building to address the complex interplay of race, gender, and discipline. We posit that school social workers can play a pivotal role in developing intersectional tier-2 restorative practices that center the lived experiences of Black girls to reduce inequitable school discipline outcomes.
References
Annamma, S. A., Anyon, Y., Joseph, N. M., Farrar, J., Greer, E., Downing, B., & Simmons, J. (2019). Black girls and school discipline: The complexities of being overrepresented and understudied. Urban Education, 54(2), 211-242. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085916646610
Anyon, Y., Atteberry-Ash, B., Yang, J., Pauline, M., Wiley, K., Cash, D., Downing, B., Greer, E., & Pisciotta, L. (2018). It’s all about the relationships”: Educators’ rationales and strategies for building connections with students to prevent exclusionary school discipline outcomes. Children & Schools, 40(4), 221-230. https://doi.org/10.1093/cs/cdy017
Anyon, Y., Gregory, A., Stone, S., Farrar, J., Jenson, J. M., McQueen, J., Greer, B., & Simmons, J. (2016b). Restorative interventions and school discipline sanctions in a large urban school district. American Educational Research Journal, 53(6), 1663-1697. https://doi.org/10.3102/0002831216675719
Anyon, Y., Jenson, J. M., Altschul, I., Farrar, J., McQueen, J., Greer, E., Downing, B., & Simmons, J. (2014). The persistent effect of race and the promise of alternatives to suspension in school discipline outcomes. Children and Youth Services Review, 44, 379-386. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.childyouth.2014.06.025
Arum, R. (2003). Restoring moral authority in American schools. In Judging School Discipline (pp. 188-214). Harvard University Press. https://doi.org/10.4159/9780674020290-007
Augustine, C. H., Engberg, J., Grimm, G. E., Lee, E., Wang, E. L., Christianson, K., & Joseph, A. (2018). Can restorative practices improve school climate and curb suspensions? An evaluation of the impact of restorative practices in a mid-sized urban school. National Institute for Justice. https://doi.org/10.7249/RR2840
Ball, S. J. (2016). Neoliberal education? Confronting the slouching beast. Policy Futures in Education, 14(8), 1046-1059. https://doi.org/10.1177/1478210316664259
Baumle, D. (2018). Creating the trauma‐to‐prison pipeline: How the US justice system criminalizes structural and interpersonal trauma experienced by girls of color. Family Court Review, 56(4), 695-708. https://doi.org/10.1111/fcre.12384
Bazeley, P., & Jackson, K. (2019). Qualitative data analysis with Nvivo. Sage Publications Limited. Los Angeles, CA
Bourdieu, P. (1984). Distinction: A social critique of taste (R. Nice, Trans.). Harvard University Press.
Bronfenbrenner, U. (1979). The ecology of human development: Experiments in nature and design. Harvard University Press. https://doi.org/10.4159/9780674028845
Brown, T. M. (2007). Lost and turned out: Academic, social, and emotional experiences of students excluded from school. Urban Education, 42(5), 432-455. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085907304947
Buckmaster, D. (2016). From the eradication of tolerance to the restoration of school community: Exploring restorative practices as a reform framework for ethical school discipline. Values & Ethics in Educational Administration, 12(3), 1-8. http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1186305.pdf
Bollmer, J., Bethel, J., Munk, T., & Bitterman, A. (2011). Methods for assessing racial/ethnic disproportionality in special education: A technical assistance guide (Revised ed.). Data Accountability Center, Westat. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED577280.pdf
Costello, B., Wachtel, J., & Wachtel, T. (2009). Restorative circles in schools: Building community and enhancing learning. International Institute for Restorative Practices.
Cregor, M., & Hewitt, D. (2011). Dismantling the school-to-prison pipeline: A survey from the field. Poverty & Race, 20(1), 5-7. https://naacpldf.org/wp-content/uploads/PRRAC-journal-Jan_Feb-2011-Dismantling_the_School-to-Prison_Pipeline-1.pdf
Crenshaw, K. (1995). Mapping the margins: Intersectionality, identity politics, and violence against women of color) In K. Crenshaw, N. Gotanda, G. Peller, & K. Thomas (Eds.), Critical race theory: The writings that formed the movement (chap. 7, pp. 357-383). The New Press.
Crenshaw, K. W., Ocen, P., & Nanda, J. (2015). Black girls matter: Pushed out, overpoliced, and underprotected. African American Policy Forum. Center for Intersectionality and Social Policy Studies. https://www.atlanticphilanthropies.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/BlackGirlsMatter_Report.pdf
Darensbourg, A., Perez, E., & Blake, J. J. (2010). Overrepresentation of African American males in exclusionary discipline: the role of school-based mental health professionals in dismantling the school to prison pipeline. Journal of African American Males in Education (JAAME), 1(3), 196-211. https://jaamejournal.scholasticahq.com/article/18404-overrepresentation-ofafrican-american-males-in-exclusionary-discipline-the-role-of-school-based-mental-health-professionals-in-dismantling-the-school
Drewery, W. (2004). Conferencing in schools: Punishment, restorative justice, and the productive importance of the process of conversation. Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology, 14(5), 332-344. https://doi.org/10.1002/casp.800
Duncan, G. A. (2002). Critical race theory and method: Rendering race in urban ethnographic research. Qualitative Inquiry, 8(1), 85-104. https://doi.org/10.1177/107780040200800106
Dupper, D. R., Theriot, M. T., & Craun, S. W. (2009). Reducing out-of-school suspensions: Practice guidelines for school social workers. Children & Schools, 31(1), 6-14. https://doi.org/10.1093/cs/31.1.6
Emerson, R. M., Fretz, R. I., & Shaw, L. L. (2011). Writing ethnographic fieldnotes. University of Chicago Press. https://doi.org/10.7208/chicago/9780226206851.001.0001
Epstein, G., González, T., & Javdani, S. (2020). Data snapshot: 2017-2018 National data on school discipline by race and gender. Georgetown Law Center on Poverty and Inequality. https://genderjusticeandopportunity.georgetown.edu/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/National-Data-on-School-Discipline-by-Race-and-Gender.pdf
Epstein, R., Blake, J. J., & Gonzalez, T. (2017). Girlhood interrupted: The erasure of Black girls’ childhood. Georgetown Law - Center on Poverty & Inequality. https://jjie.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/girlhood-interrupted.pdf
Fallo, K. L., & Larwin, K. H. (2022). The implementation of restorative justice practices: What does six years of data reveal about the changes in the reported discipline rates for African American students? Journal of Education, 204(1), 58-70. https://doi.org/10.1177/00220574221090286
Galman, S. C. (2018). Shane, the lone ethnographer: A beginner's guide to ethnography. Rowman & Littlefield.
Green, J., Willis, K., Hughes, E., Small, R., Welch, N., Gibbs, L., & Daly, J. (2007). Generating best evidence from qualitative research: the role of data analysis. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health, 31(6), 545-550.
Greene, R. R. (2008). Human behavior theory & social work practice (3rd ed.). Aldine Transaction.
Gregory, A., Clawson, K., Davis, A., & Gerewitz, J. (2016). The promise of restorative practices to transform teacher-student relationships and achieve equity in school discipline. Journal of Educational and Psychological Consultation,26, 325-353. https://doi.org/10.1080/10474412.2014.929950
Gregory, A., Skiba, R. J., & Noguera, P. A. (2010). The achievement gap and the discipline gap: Two sides of the same coin? Educational Researcher, 39(1), 59-68. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X09357621
Hanson, A. L. (2005). Have zero tolerance school discipline policies turned into a nightmare-The American dream's promise of equal educational opportunity grounded in Brown v. Board of Education. UC Davis Journal of Juvenile Law & Policy, 9(2), 289-379. https://sjlr.law.ucdavis.edu/sites/g/files/dgvnsk15361/files/media/documents/SJLR-9-2-Hanson.pdf
Hashim, A. K., Strunk, K. O., & Dhaliwal, T. K. (2018). Justice for all? Suspension bans and restorative justice programs in the Los Angeles Unified School District. Peabody Journal of Education, 93(2), 174-189. https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2018.1435040
Hill, L. A. (2018). Disturbing disparities: Black girls and the school-to-prison pipeline. Fordham Law Review Online, 87, 58-63. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3379909
Houston, S. (2002). Reflecting on habitus, field and capital towards a culturally sensitive social work. Journal of Social Work, 2(2), 149-167. https://doi.org/10.1177/146801730200200203
Howell, J., & Caisey, A. (2019). What we need is education: Differentiating the mechanisms contributing to persistent racial inequality of education. Phylon, 56(1), 58-80. https://www.jstor.org/stable/26743831
Iowa Department of Education. (2019). Explanation of simple risk ratio. Author. https://educate.iowa.gov/media/4834/download?inline
Ispa-Landa, S. (2018). Persistently harsh punishments amid efforts to reform: Using tools from social psychology to counteract racial bias in school disciplinary decisions. Educational Researcher, 47(6), 384-390. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X18779578
Jayakumar, U. M., & Kohli, R. (2023). Silenced and pushed out: The harms of CRT-bans on K-12 teachers. Thresholds in Education, 46(1), 1-7. https://doi.org/10.3102/2105858
Joseph, A. A., Wilcox, S. M., Hnilica, R. J., & Hansen, M. C. (2020). Keeping race at the center of school discipline practices and trauma-informed care: An interprofessional framework. Children & Schools, 42(3), 161-170. https://doi.org/10.1093/cs/cdaa013
Joseph-McCatty, A., Bamwine, P., & Sanders, J. (2024). The case for an intersectional approach to trauma-informed practices in K–12 schools for Black girls. Children & Schools, 46(3), 156-165. https://doi.org/10.1093/cs/cdae010
Joseph, A., Hnilica, R. J., & Hanson, M. (2021). Using restorative practices to reduce racially disproportionate school suspensions: The barriers school leaders should consider during the first year of implementation. Taboo: The Journal of Culture and Education, 20(2), 1-26. https://digitalscholarship.unlv.edu/taboo/vol20/iss2/6
Kozol, J. (2012). Savage inequalities: Children in America's schools. Crown.
Levine, R. F. (2019). When race meets class: African Americans coming of age in a small city. Routledge.
Lewis, A. E., & Diamond, J. B. (2015). Despite the best intentions: How racial inequality thrives in good schools. Oxford University Press.
Lewis, S. (2009). Improving school climate: Findings from schools implementing restorative practices. International Institute for Restorative Practices. https://www-iirp-edu.webpkgcache.com/doc/-/s/www.iirp.edu/pdf/IIRP-Improving-School-Climate-2009.pdf
Lodi, E., Perrella, L., Lepri, G. L., Scarpa, M. L., & Patrizi, P. (2022). Use of restorative justice and restorative practices at school: A systematic literature review. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19(1), 1-34. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph19010096
Lustick, H. (2017). Making discipline relevant: Toward a theory of culturally responsive positive schoolwide discipline. Race Ethnicity and Education, 20(5), 681-695. https://doi.org/10.1080/13613324.2016.1150828
Lustick, H. (2021). “Restorative justice” or restoring order? Restorative school discipline practices in urban public schools. Urban Education, 56(8), 1269-1296. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085917741725
Mansfield, K. C., Fowler, B., & Rainbolt, S. (2018). The potential of restorative practices to ameliorate discipline gaps: The story of one high school’s leadership team. Educational Administration Quarterly, 54(2), 303-323. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013161X17751178
Morrison, K. (2018). Students’ perceptions of unfair discipline in school. The Journal of Classroom Interaction, 53(2), 21-45. http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1255094.pdf
Morris, M. W. (2016). Pushout: The criminalization of Black girls in schools. The New Press.
Morris, M. W. (2022). Cultivating joyful learning spaces for Black girls: Insights into interrupting school pushout. ASCD.
Office of Civil Rights [OCR]. (2016). 2013-2014 Civil rights data collection: A first look - Key data highlights on equity and opportunity gaps in our nation's public schools. U.S. Department of Education for Civil Rights. https://www2.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ocr/docs/2013-14-first-look.pdf
Rothery, M. (2016). Critical ecological systems theory. In N. Coady & P. Lehmann (Eds.), Theoretical perspectives for direct social work practice: A generalist eclectic approach (2nd ed., pp. 106-135). Springer.
Saldaña, J. (2015). The coding manual for qualitative researchers. Sage.
Siccama, C. J., & Penna, S. (2008). Enhancing validity of a qualitative dissertation research study by using NVivo. Qualitative Research Journal, 8(2), 91-103. https://doi.org/10.3316/QRJ0802091
Simonpillai, R. (2021, September 21). On these grounds: A shocking film about police brutality in US schools. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/film/2021/sep/21/on-these-grounds-documentary-police-brutality-us-schools
Skiba, R. J., Michael, R. S., Nardo, A. C., & Peterson, R. L. (2002). The color of discipline: Sources of racial and gender disproportionality in school punishment. The Urban Review, 34, 317-342. https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1021320817372
Smith, A. L. (2019). Theorizing Black girlhood. In A. S. Halliday (Ed.), The Black girlhood studies collection (pp. 21-44). Women’s Press.
Suarez, C. E., Owens, D. R., Hunter, J. D., Menzies, C., & Dixson, A. D. (2021). SquadGoals: Intersectionality, mentorship, and women of color in the academy. In M. Lynn & A. D. Dixon (Eds.), Handbook of critical race theory in education (pp. 93-107). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781351032223
Teasley, M. L., Spencer, M. S., & Bartholomew, M. (Eds.). (2023). Social work and the grand challenge to eliminate racism: Concepts, theory, and evidence based approaches. Oxford University Press, Incorporated. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780197674949.001.0001
Tobin, T. J., & Vincent, C. G. (2011). Strategies for preventing disproportionate exclusions of African American students. Preventing School Failure: Alternative Education for Children and Youth, 55(4), 192-201. https://doi.org/10.1080/1045988X.2010.532520
Toldson, I. A., McGee, T., & Lemmons, B. P. (2015). Reducing suspensions by improving academic engagement among school-age Black males. In A. J. Artiles & E. B. Kozleski (Eds.), Closing the school discipline gap: Equitable remedies for excessive exclusion (pp. 107-117). Teachers College Press.
Turner, E. O., & Beneke, A. J. (2020). ‘Softening’ school resource officers: The extension of police presence in schools in an era of Black Lives Matter, school shootings, and rising inequality. Race Ethnicity and Education, 23(2), 221-240. https://doi.org/10.1080/13613324.2019.1679753
Tyler-Wood, T., Cereijo, M. V. P., & Pemberton, J. B. (2004). Comparison of discipline referrals for students with emotional/behavioral disorders under differing instructional arrangements. Preventing School Failure: Alternative Education for Children and Youth, 48(4), 30-33. https://doi.org/10.3200/PSFL.48.4.30-33
U.S. Commission on Civil Rights. (2019). Beyond suspensions: Examining school discipline policies and connections to the school-to-prison pipeline for students of color with disabilities. Author. www.usccr.gov/files/pubs/2019/07-23-Beyond-Suspensions.pdf
United States Department of Education [USDOE]. (2019). 2015-2016 Civil rights data collection: School climate and safety - Data highlights on school climate and safety in our nation's public schools. Office of Civil Rights. https://www2.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ocr/docs/school-climate-and-safety.pdf
USDOE, & United States Department of Justice [DOJ]. (2014). Dear colleague letter on the nondiscriminatory administration of school discipline [Rescinded]. Author. https://www2.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ocr/letters/colleague-201401-title-vi.pdf
Vavrus, F., & Cole, K. (2002). "I didn't do nothin'": The discursive construction of school suspension. The Urban Review, 34, 87-111. https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1015375215801
Wallace Jr, J. M., Goodkind, S., Wallace, C. M., & Bachman, J. G. (2008). Racial, ethnic, and gender differences in school discipline among U.S. high school students: 1991-2005. The Negro Educational Review, 59(1-2), 47-62. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2678799/
Wachtel, T. (2013). Defining restorative. International Institute for Restorative Practices. https://www-iirp-edu.webpkgcache.com/doc/-/s/www.iirp.edu/images/pdf/Defining-Restorative_Nov-2016.pdf
Welsh, R. O., & Little, S. (2018). The school discipline dilemma: A comprehensive review of disparities and alternative approaches. Review of educational research, 88(5), 752-794. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654318791582
Yassine, J., Tipton‐Fisler, L. A., & Katic, B. (2020). Building student‐teacher relationships and improving behaviour‐management for classroom teachers. Support for Learning, 35(3), 389-407. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9604.12317
Young, J. L. (2020). Black girls and women in K-12 educational settings: A content analysis of publications in selected journals from 2000-2015. The Urban Review, 52(3), 603-622. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11256-020-00582-y
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Andrea Joseph-McCatty, Dr. Sara Goodkind, Kenyette Garrett, Corrina Joyner
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
